HEADLINES

Syria: UN Report – Assad Edited Out Evidence Of War Crimes

BY Roy Gutman, January 29, 2016. First appeared in Foreign Policy (01/27/16).

Syria: Starvation is another weapon of war, and children are the most vulnerable victims. As Syrian civilians starved to death, U.N. officials let the government in Damascus alter its master plan for saving lives. Its title is prosaic and its content dry, but the stark statistics in the U.N.’s annual summary of relief programs tell the story of Syria’s humanitarian nightmare. Syria: Starvation is another weapon of war, and children are the most vulnerable victims. As Syrian civilians starved to death, U.N. officials let the government in Damascus alter its master plan for saving lives. Its title is prosaic and its content dry, but the stark statistics in the U.N.’s annual summary of relief programs tell the story of Syria’s humanitarian nightmare.

United Nations Humanitarian Response Plan: Its title is prosaic and its content dry, but the stark statistics in the U.N.’s annual summary of relief programs tell the story of Syria’s humanitarian nightmare.

Syria is a country on life support

  • 13.6 million people are in need of humanitarian assistance,
  • Syrians are being displaced at a rate of 50 families per hour every day, and
  • at least 1 million people in displaced persons camps receive no international aid.
Syrian child, (Photo: Reform4Syria)

Syrian refugee child. (Photo: Reform4Syria).

But to close readers of the U.N. Humanitarian Response Plan, which was published on Dec. 29, (2016) the big surprise was what the 64-page document failed to mention.

The United Nations, after consulting the Syrian government, altered dozens of passages and omitted pertinent information to paint the government of Bashar al-Assad in a more favorable light.

By comparing the final document to an earlier draft that was obtained by Foreign Policy,

  • (removed were) 10 references to “sieged” or “besieged” areas, such as that in Madaya;
  • (removed is) southwestern town in Syria that saw 23 people die of starvation over several months before the arrival of a U.N. aid convoy in mid-January.
  • Gone was any mention of the program to clear mines and unexploded [sic] ordnance, such as the “barrel bombs” the regime drops indiscriminately on populated areas.
  • Gone were all mentions of Syrian relief groups that shepherd the aid to civilians in rebel-held areas.

The U.N. Office for the Coordination of Humanitarian Affairs (OCHA) indicated that the alterations were made at the behest of the Syrian government.

It is standard procedure in each country for the UN to consult with the government of the country,” wrote Linda Tom, an OCHA spokeswoman, when asked about the deletion of references to “siege” or “besieged.” Amanda Pitt, OCHA’s chief spokeswoman, affirmed that point.

  • I assume it was done in consultation with a range of partners including the Government, as is normal practice,” she said in an email (to Foreign Policy). 

OCHA declined to make any senior official available for an interview or to respond to further questions.

Syria: Two little boys on the dirt floor with a bowl of food. (Photo: Google).

Syria: Two little boys on the dirt floor with a bowl of food. (Photo: Google).

The U.N.’s deletion of any mention of sieges is particularly noteworthy, because the Madaya crisis is far from over.

Although the Syrian government allowed U.N. agencies […] to truck in food and some medical supplies,

Hezbollah and Syrian army forces (then) restricted the delivery of fuel, allowing only a fraction of what the U.N. had planned.

Lebanon’s Hezbollah militia and the regime blocked the evacuation of hundreds of people with acute malnutrition who doctors want taken to hospitals, relief officials said.

Thirteen more civilians died after the arrival of the aid convoys, Mohammad Yusuf, coordinator of a local Madaya medical unit, told (Foreign Policy) on Wednesday.

The international body has come under widespread criticism for staying silent for months on Madaya until the photos of children who had died of starvation began to circulate.

The U.N. ordinarily says little about the situation in regions under siege, preferring quiet diplomacy — but that approach didn’t work in 2015,

  • as the Syrian government turned down nine out of 10 requests to send food and medicine to areas that the U.N. classified as besieged or “hard to reach.”

In a “Flash Update” made public on Jan. 17, however, U.N. officials disclosed that they had been unable to obtain approval for medical evacuations.

The update said at one point that several cases” require urgent specialized care outside Madaya, and elsewhere that “dozens of individuals” needed such help.

One teenage boy passed away before the eyes of a UNICEF official.

While 10 people were evacuated in the last days, approvals for the evacuation of others [remain] pending,” it said.

Local residents and rescue workers help a migrant woman after a boat carrying migrants sank off the island of Rhodes in southeastern Greece on April 20, 2015.

Local residents and rescue workers help a migrant woman after a boat carrying migrants sank off the island of Rhodes in southeastern Greece on April 20, 2015.

Representatives of two Syrian relief organizations told (Foreign Policy) that the OCHA bulletin drastically underestimated the number of people in need of urgent case, saying that as many as 400 people need to be evacuated.

Hezbollah has tightened the siege still more in recent days, forcing dozens of families on the road to Zabadani to leave their homes for Madaya, according to two NGOs and a town resident.

But the U.N. hasn’t issued a bulletin on the situation in the town since Jan. 17.

Meanwhile, criticism of the U.N.’s handling of sieges hasn’t only been over Madaya.

Five Syrian relief organizations charged that the U.N. had set an “unacceptable precedent” in negotiating the wording of the report with the Syrian government.

  • Removing all references to besieged areas “downplays the severity of the violations” of international law by the Assad regime, and
  • removing the references to mine clearing was an implicit validation of the Syrian government’s position that mine removal constitutes military action, they said in a letter sent on Dec. 30.
Syrian child peeps through a tent at Ain al-Helweh refugee camp. (Photo: UNICEF)

Syrian child peeps through a tent at Ain al-Helweh refugee camp. (Photo: UNICEF)

Some aid workers believe that the U.N.’s willingness to toe the Syrian government’s line is due to the international body’s fear of being booted out of Damascus.

In a separate letter on Jan. 13, 112 relief workers from government-besieged areas complained bitterly that staff in the U.N.’s Damascus office, relief workers and civil society activists wrote:

  • are either too close to the regime or too scared of having their visas revoked by the same powers that are besieging us.
  • Why are you silencing our suffering? As if refusing to break the sieges were not enough, it now seems the UN is even afraid of uttering the words,

Both letters were addressed to Stephen O’Brien, the U.N. undersecretary-general for humanitarian affairs and emergency relief coordinator, who replied in a Jan. 17 letter to “members of Syrian civil society” that appeared to respond to both complaints.

He asserted that the U.N. was not,

  • too close to any party” and was not “acting in such a way to encourage the use of siege tactics.

He said the U.N. had,

  • repeatedly and unequivocally called for an end to siege as a weapon of war against civilians and for full, unhindered, unconditional and sustained access to all people in need in besieged and hard-to-reach areas in Syria.”

He also said he was,

  • angry and frustrated about the situation in besieged areas in Syria and the terrifying toll it is having on its children, women and men.
Kevin Kennedy, UN Stabilization Mission in Haiti

Kevin Kennedy, UN Stabilization Mission in Haiti

There is no suggestion, however, that U.N. officials will review their standing policy of negotiating in secret for approval to deliver food and medicine, a mission that the U.N. Security Council has unanimously endorsed.

Kevin Kennedy, the U.N.’s regional coordinator for the Syria crisis, pushed back more vigorously earlier this month in Gaziantep, Turkey, during encounters with international and independent Syrian relief agencies.

In those discussions, he dismissed the importance of the Humanitarian Response Plan, according to two attendees.

  • He said the document is meaningless, and it will be put back on the shelf,” said a Syrian relief staffer who attended one of the meetings.

While the U.N. describes the Humanitarian Response Plan as,

  • the collective vision of the international humanitarian community and its national partners for responding to the assessed humanitarian needs in Syria,”

Kennedy downplayed its influence at the Gazientep meeting.

  • He said donors don’t care about this document,” the relief staffer said.
  • It was a very bad meeting, with irritating answers,” said a second aid agency official, who is a representative of an independent Syrian organization. “There is no willingness to make any change.

The biggest single donor to the U.N.’s $3.2 billion program, the United States, also played down the dispute.

The U.S. Agency for International Development, in an email to (Foreign Policy), called the Humanitarian Response Plan

  • an operational plan, not an advocacy or fundraising document.

But some aid organizations are not willing to dismiss it so quickly.

The document, in the words of one senior official of a U.S. relief organization,

  • sets the direction and the tone” for the international response to the crisis.

Some fear the language in official documents can also take on a life of its own – with the Assad regime using it for its own purposes – regardless of how U.N. officials see it.

  • If it’s important, don’t let the government of Syria do whatever it wants to with it,” said the second aid official.

Foreign Policy: How the U.N. Let Assad Edit the Truth of Syria’s War

🔝

Click Picture for a Popular Article

  • A Palestinian girl and women figth to free a Palestinian boy (bottom) held by an Israeli soldier (C) during clashes between Israeli security forces and Palestinian protesters following a march against Palestinian land confiscation to expand the nearby Jewish Hallamish settlement on August 28, 2015 in the West Bank village of Nabi Saleh near Ramallah. AFP PHOTO / ABBAS MOMANI
  • And now - a country with more than 10,000 people killed in the ensuing violence, over 10,000 more died of starvation under the blockade of humanitarian aid and supplies - the Middle East’s poorest nation, Yemen is reduced to the brink of famine.
  • A malnourished child lies on a weighing machine at a therapeutic feeding Centre at Al Sabyeen hospital in Sana’a. (Reuters)
  • Ronald Reagan meets Afghan Mujahideen Commanders at the White House in 1985.
  • The teenager, Nihad Barakat Shamo Alawsi, was taken to Syria and then to the Islamic State stronghold of Mosul in northern Iraq, she told an event in London on Wednesday. "They raped us, they killed our men, they took our babies away from us," Alawsi, now 17, said at the event organised by the UK-based AMAR Foundation, a charity that provides education and healthcare in the Middle East.
  • Donald Trump Jumps The Shark
  • Russia's Foreign Minister Lavrov listens to U.S. Secretary of State Kerry during a press conference at the United Nations Headquarters in Manhattan, New York
  • People searched for survivors in the rubble of houses destroyed by an airstrike in Sana, Yemen, on June 12. (Photo: Mohamed Al-Sayaghi/Reuters) alistairreignblog.com
  • Painted on the side of a building in Bristol, southwest England - home of the celebrated graffiti artist Banksy - the image reprises a 1979 photograph of Soviet leader Leonid Brezhnev and East German President Erich Honecker kissing, which was later turned into a mural on the Berlin Wall. It was commissioned by pro-EU campaign group "We are Europe" as what they call a warning of things to come if Britons vote to leave the 28-member bloc on June 23, as advocated by both Johnson and Trump, the presumptive Republican candidate in November's U.S. presidential election. Johnson is the "Out" campaign's best-known leader and Trump has said Britain would be "better off without" the EU, which he has blamed for Europe's migration crisis.
  • The month is also a time of community; it is the custom for Muslims to invite their neighbours and friends to share their evening meal – iftar – and recite special Tarawih prayers in congregation. It is also a time when Muslims try to reconnect with the Qur’an, which they believe is the word of God. However, Children, people who are sick or who have mental illness, elderly people for example do not have to fast.
  • The Prime Minister, Justin Trudeau, today announced that the Centre for Commercialization of Regenerative Medicine (CCRM) will receive $20 million – under the Advanced Manufacturing Fund (AMF) – to establish and operate the Centre for Advanced Therapeutic Cell Technologies. January 13, 2006. (Photo: Adam Scotti). AlistairReignBlog.com
  • Refugee-girl-cries-as-her-Central-American-shanty-town-is-destroyed-0714-by-Spencer-Platt

Click Picture for a Popular Cartoon

  • Way-back Machine: Who Vogue'd It Best? Take our poll at Alistair Reign News Blog: AlistairReignBlog.com
  • Sesame Street - Grouch Apprentice with Donald Grump
  • When cartoons turn into people
  • Includes Meryl Streep's full Golden Globe speech, a peek at her stage performance where she play Donald Trump, SAG Speeches: Ashton Kutcher, Julia Louis-Dreyfus, Kerry Washington, Natalie Portman, Lily Tomlin and others, as well as talk show host's comments and interviews. Tied together with indie music and skits of Peter Griffin of Family Guy playing Donald Trump.
  • Nicki 'Minnie' Minaj
  • Caption this winner sept 1
  • Donald Trump for President
  • Take Our Poll: Come on in and decide for yourself! Who worked the puffy white shirt best?
  • Donald Trump for President of the (Mexican free and NOW Muslim free) United Sates of America. (AlistairReignBlog.com),
  • The moment Bruce Jenner realized he was a woman

Start a Conversation or Write a Caption This joke.

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s